PubsandBeer

History: Home > The Black Eel

The Black Eel (Draughts London Ltd)

Beer (sort)Average Score (sort)No. Samples (sort)
Exale - Best BitterGood1
Adnams - Ghost Ship - Pale AleNot Tried0

Visits Details

14 Nov 2026 (Hogan Sampling)
3rd visit of the outing: Another first foray here. Busy footfall for my mid-afternoon visit and where I tracked down the assembled members of the East London and City CAMRA branch for their afternoon-into-early evening trek of real ale pubs to promote their Round Chapel beer and cider festival in early December. Prompt, friendly service and seating to be had despite being very busy. Wonderful to see the original tiling from its Eel, Pie & Mash Shop days all intact. Superbly refurbished as a pub and looking suitably ancient to blend in, and with a new bar running down the right-hand side as you enter but it looks totally the part. There are two handpumps and one selling an Exale cask beer on this visit. A very interesting walk through the backstreets brought me here and past Canonbury Tower, a 66-foot (20-metre) red-brick Tudor structure built between 1509 and 1532, making it the oldest surviving building in Islington, North London. Originally constructed as part of a country manor house for the canons of St Bartholomew's Priory, the Grade II-listed landmark has served as a noble residence and a literary retreat. Much of the surrounding Tudor manor house was demolished and replaced with Georgian houses in the 1790s, leaving the tower as the primary survivor. Restored by the 5th Marquess of Northampton in 1907–1908, the building served as a social club and later housed the Tavistock Repertory Company (known as the Tower Theatre) for 50 years until 2003. Today, it is used as a Masonic research centre and occasionally opens to the public via Islington Guided Walks.
BeerABVScoreNotes
Exale - Best Bitter4.40GoodHead and lacing on being served but not lasting on this East London bitter from Walthamstow’s famed Blackhorse Beer Mile, where Exale Brewing first cracked open its doors in late 2019, pouring their inaugural drops in December 2019 before formally incorporating in 2020 and setting up camp inside a cavernous former furniture factory at Unit 2C, Uplands Business Park, E17. This independent East End crew has expanded its turf across London’s pub scene, serving up small-batch cask and keg at their Walthamstow taproom alongside sister boozers like Hackney’s Three Colts Tavern and The Black Eel. A dry bitter first hit on this chestnut-amber coloured brew. A crisp hoppiness rising from its East Kent Goldings releasing a honeyed floral scent with a hint of sweet spice and Fuggles behind a damp woodland earthiness and hedgerow leafiness, and frequently backed by Challenger for clean kettle bittering and a green-hop snap. A biscuity, bready maltiness rising and in following what makes a traditional London Best Bitter just that, with a pairing of Maris Otter Pale Ale Malt lending fresh-baked loaf and digestive biscuit flavours, and Crystal Malt exuding burnt sugar and sticky toffee, often bolstered by a touch of Amber or Biscuit Malt adding a dry, toasted crustiness. A caramel-infused biscuity body holding on for me. A dry herbal bitterness lingering with a hint of meadow blossoms, toffee and freshly turned earth mixed with an orchard fruitiness. Served in good condition taste-wise but not keeping it head and lacing suggests perhaps on its way out.
Adnams - Ghost Ship - Pale Ale4.10Not Tried

About The Black Eel

Summary of Beer Scores

 Total
Exceptional-
Excellent-
Good1
Acceptable-
Poor-

Website.

The pub is found in Dalston, Greater London, E8 2JS.

Found at 41 Kingsland High Street in Dalston, it opened as a pub in October 2025, taking over the Grade II-listed building that originally operated as F. Cooke’s eel, pie and mash shop. Dubbed the "Buckingham Palace" of pie shops, the Edwardian venue was a famous East End eel house frequented by Cockney rock duo, Chas & Dave, who even hosted a 1977 album launch party there. Walthamstow-based Exale Brewing transformed the landmark into The Black Eel, opening on 24th October 2025, while retaining its historic Art Nouveau glazed wall tiles, eel motifs, marble counters, and stained-glass domed skylights. A treat to behold! The Cooke family, one of London's three great pie-and-mash dynasties, alongside Manze and Kelly, first established their business in Shoreditch in 1862, a date still commemorated in the original doorway mosaic at the Dalston shop. The four-storey building at 41 Kingsland High Street was erected in 1902–03 by architect, James Hood, opening specifically as Fred Cooke’s lavishly decorated eel, pie, and mash shop in 1910 and with a rear dining room added in 1936. After the eel, pie and mash shop closed, it became a Chinese Restaurant then a games bar. Reopened by Exale Brewing as a bar/community space, it has sizeable rear areas, including a ballroom and a games area. There is a rear garden with seating for 150 people, a pétanque court and an eel tank but no eels now by all accounts. The pub's kitchen serves Mediterranean-inspired food and Sunday roasts rather than the traditional East End jellied or stewed eels.

We have visited this pub once, seen 2 different beers and tried 1 of them.

Postcode: E8 2JS