| Who | Score | When | Notes |
|---|
| Philip Pirrip |  | 08 Nov 2025 | What I came for and quite as it should be |
| Philip Pirrip | | 22 Oct 2025 | Exactly what I wanted and exactly what I got |
| Philip Pirrip |  | 08 Sep 2025 | Very good but not quite there |
| Philip Pirrip | | 14 Jul 2025 | Absolute delight |
| Philip Pirrip | | 04 Jun 2025 | Everything I wanted |
| Philip Pirrip | | 06 Dec 2024 | No need to move on to any other ales here tonight |
| Philip Pirrip | | 13 Nov 2024 | Did I just perhaps find the second one a tad better than the first, slightly creamier. Whatever, an apt nightcap |
| Philip Pirrip | | 23 Sep 2024 | So lucky to have this as an all year round ale |
| Philip Pirrip | | 11 Sep 2024 | As yesterday great creamy head and lacing - a fine drop |
| Philip Pirrip | | 10 Sep 2024 | Creamy and smooth on the palate |
| Philip Pirrip | | 31 Aug 2024 | Creamy headed |
| Philip Pirrip | Not Tried | 27 Aug 2024 | Oh dear. Inspired me as I walked in to see it on but as I ordered it was just taken off sale as had run out. Ouch! Should have gone on it upon entering |
| Philip Pirrip | | 20 Aug 2024 | As good as yesterday's and why I had come back for more |
| Philip Pirrip | | 19 Aug 2024 | First rate with an almost Guinness-like creamy head |
| Philip Pirrip | | 16 Aug 2024 | Just the ale I hoped would be on |
| Philip Pirrip | | 26 Jul 2024 | Creamy headed Tally Ho! |
| Philip Pirrip | | 12 Jul 2024 | 4½* Near perfect and head and lacing until the end, to boot |
| Philip Pirrip | | 05 Jul 2024 | Tally at its best |
| Philip Pirrip | | 28 Jun 2024 | Made up for the relative disappointments of the other 2 beers tonight |
| Philip Pirrip | | 01 Mar 2024 | In full flavoured form |
| Philip Pirrip | Not Tried | 26 Jan 2024 | Spot on, fresh on tonight and and very well balanced |
| Philip Pirrip | | 17 Jan 2024 | Badged as Tally Ho! Ho! Ho! Matt barman insistent that Palmers cellar services on a recent visit insisted this is a slightly different festive brew to Ho! |
| Philip Pirrip | | 12 Jan 2024 | Fine form, no need to drink any other ale here tonight |
| Philip Pirrip | | 20 Dec 2023 | Top form |
| Philip Pirrip | | 19 Dec 2023 | New cask on tonight |
| Philip Pirrip | | 15 Dec 2023 | Delicious and condition spot on |
| Philip Pirrip | | 01 Dec 2023 | Boot-fillingly moreish |
| Philip Pirrip | | 28 Nov 2023 | 2 quickest pints as was so moreish |
| Philip Pirrip | | 13 Oct 2023 | The doctor could have ordered nothing better for me |
| Philip Pirrip | | 20 Sep 2023 | A warming brew helped me to dry out |
| Philip Pirrip | | 15 Sep 2023 | Spot on |
| Philip Pirrip | | 30 Aug 2023 | As expected here |
| Philip Pirrip | | 21 Aug 2023 | Just what the doctor ordered |
| Philip Pirrip | | 05 Aug 2023 | 2nd day cask on - in peak condition |
| Philip Pirrip | | 29 Jul 2023 | Says something when the very last half out of the cask is pulled and is still up there |
| Philip Pirrip | | 29 Jul 2023 | Nearing end of cask but no loss of condition |
| Philip Pirrip | | 28 Jul 2023 | 2nd day of this cask. Ideal condition |
| Philip Pirrip | | 21 Jul 2023 | Just as it should be |
| Philip Pirrip | | 01 Jul 2023 | Spiffing pints |
| Philip Pirrip | | 30 Jun 2023 | Very very downable |
| Philip Pirrip | | 20 Jun 2023 | Blissful enough |
| Philip Pirrip | | 07 Jun 2023 | Almost last out of old cask and superb still. None left when tried to order an extra half at last knockings |
| Philip Pirrip | | 06 Jun 2023 | |
| Philip Pirrip | | 05 Jun 2023 | Came on yesterday and so very nourishing |
| Philip Pirrip | | 27 May 2023 | Superb |
| Philip Pirrip | | 26 May 2023 | 4½* First day on of a new cask and exceptional all round |
| Philip Pirrip | | 15 May 2023 | 2nd last and last out of cask and still excellent - but noticed a more liquorice flavour coming through |
| Philip Pirrip | | 13 May 2023 | 4½* Superb, on from today with new cask as I accurately guessed it might be |
| Philip Pirrip | | 06 May 2023 | A little more time for even more with the slight closing time extension |
| Philip Pirrip | | 24 Apr 2023 | Superb |
| Philip Pirrip | | 22 Apr 2023 | Probably an even higher score |
| Philip Pirrip | | 21 Apr 2023 | Dream came true when the succession beer board showed another beer would be next on to replace British Bulldog. Simply 4½* quality, superb |
| Philip Pirrip | | 17 Apr 2023 | As expected |
| Philip Pirrip | | 15 Apr 2023 | A must if it is on the board |
| Philip Pirrip | | 10 Apr 2023 | 4½* Unmatchable |
| Philip Pirrip | | 18 Mar 2023 | Superb |
| Philip Pirrip | | 11 Mar 2023 | A perfect substitute for Palmers IPA being unavailable! Almost more than |
| Philip Pirrip | | 18 Feb 2023 | Superb - almost tempted to give 4½* |
| Philip Pirrip | | 23 Sep 2022 | Splendid form |
| Philip Pirrip | | 16 Sep 2022 | Difficult to be much better |
| Philip Pirrip |  | 03 Sep 2022 | One word - superb. 4½* |
| Philip Pirrip | | 20 Aug 2022 | Made a pair of 4½* ales here tonight. This stuff was just glug glug glug |
| Philip Pirrip | | 16 Jul 2022 | Perhaps rather woodier than usual |
| Philip Pirrip | | 09 Jul 2022 | A slightly sweet one to follow Palmers IPA |
| Philip Pirrip | | 25 Jun 2022 | In lovely condition |
| Philip Pirrip | | 04 Jun 2022 | Lovely nightcapper |
| Philip Pirrip | | 15 Mar 2022 | 4½* bordering on perfect |
| ChrisE | Not Tried | 14 Jan 2020 | |
| Philip Pirrip | | 25 Aug 2018 | Superb nightcap |
| ChrisE | Not Tried | 10 Jan 2014 | |
| Philip Pirrip | | 29 Aug 2013 | Nightcap - tongue rasping bitterness then Zzzzzzzzzzzzzz |
